Key Difference – Monologic vs Dialogic Communication
Communication can involve interaction between two or more people and the transmission of information, but it does not always occur in a fair manner. Monologic and dialogic communications describe two types of communication patterns. The main distinction between monologic and dialogic communication is the interaction between the speaker and listener; in monologic communication, one person speaks while the other listens, while in dialogic communication, the roles of speaker and listener are interchanged within the participants.
What is Monologic Communication?
Monologic communication can be described simply as an occasion where one person speaks, and the other listens. However, there is no real interaction between participants since the communication is only one-directional. The monologic communicator is only interested in his or her own goals and has no real interest or concern for the listener’s attitudes and feelings. The communicator may also show a reluctance to talk about or listen to the other person’s ideas. He or she would frequently give negative personal judgments and negative criticism about the listener. The monologic communicator may also request the listener to say positive things about himself (about the communicator).
According to Johannsen (1996), the monologic communicator attempts to “command, coerce, manipulate, conquer, dazzle, deceive, or exploit.” He does not take others seriously since he views others as ‘things’ to be exploited. The focus in monologic communication is not on the audience’s’ or listener’s’ real needs, but on the communicators’ message and purpose. The communicator needs responses or feedback from the listeners only to further his purpose, not to help the audience understand or to clarify unclear points. In addition, monologic communicators have a superior and often condescending attitude towards the audience.
In summary, monologic communication involves control and manipulation, and there is no real interaction between the two people involved in the communication.
What is Dialogic Communication?
Dialogic communication is an interaction where each person involved plays the role of both speaker and listener. In other words, this is a communication where everyone has a chance to express themselves. Mutual understanding and empathy are hallmarks of dialogic communication. There is a deep concern and respect for the other person and the relationship between them in this type of communication.
In this type of interaction, the listeners and speakers have the right to make their own choices without coercion, pressure, fear, or the threat of punishment. Dialogic communicators avoid negative criticism and negative personal judgment and use positive criticism in their stead. The communicators always show a willingness to listen to each other and indicate involvement by giving cues such as nonverbal actions, paraphrasing, expressions of agreements, etc. Dialogic communicator also does not manipulate the conversation to achieve his or her goals.
What is the difference between Monologic and Dialogic Communication?
Type of Interaction:
Monologic Communication: One person speaks, and the other listens.
Dialogic Communication: All the participants get a chance to speak and listen.
Respect and Concern:
Monologic Communication: There is no concern or respect for the other participants.
Dialogic Communication: There is concern and respect for the other participants.
Criticism:
Monologic Communication: Monologic communicator gives negative criticism, negative personal judgments to others, but wants other to give him positive comments.
Dialogic Communication: Dialogic communicator gives positive criticism instead of negative criticism, negative personal judgments.
Control and Manipulation:
Monologic Communication: Monologic communicator uses manipulation and control.
Dialogic Communication: Dialogic communicators do not use manipulation and control.
Reference:
Johannesen, Richard L. (1996). Ethics in Human Communication, 4th ed. Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland Press.
Image Courtesy: PEXELS
Key Takeaways
- Monologic communication involves one person speaking and the other listening, while dialogic communication allows for all participants to both speak and listen.
- Dialogic communication is characterized by respect and concern for other participants, while monologic communication lacks these qualities.
- Monologic communicators use control and manipulation, while dialogic communicators do not.
